8 votes

"How to open the JavaScript console...?" is a great resource but a poor Q&A example

Thanks for bringing this up, there's a lot of merit to this given the large number of views for this question (currently greater than 154K) and the points you've made here. I agree with number 1 and ...
user avatar
  • 15k
7 votes
Accepted

Is this question subjective and opinion?

Yes, it's very subjective mate, and it'll be too broad if you post it here. You are wondering which feature to launch and how to evaluate that feature. Every feature is ok, but it all depends on ...
user avatar
  • 3,848
6 votes
Accepted

I've clarified my question, can you please consider re-opening it?

Sometimes there's multiple reasons why a question would be considered off-topic and hence placed on-hold. Initially, the question was pretty unclear as you stated above. There are still other reasons ...
user avatar
  • 15k
5 votes
Accepted

Would this SEO question be a good fit to migrate here?

I think it would be a good fit here, too. However the question is too old to be migrated. However, if someone were to re-ask it here I would think it would be kept open.
user avatar
  • 85.7k
5 votes

adsense question ok?

We have lots of questions about AdSense. AdSense is a service that is used by many webmasters. AdSense questions are on-topic. You'll have to find a way to phrase your question to be applicable to ...
user avatar
4 votes
Accepted

Edit / Reedit question

I saw the beginnings of that edit war yesterday after you edited it and he reverted it. For the record here is a direct link to the edit diffs. I don't think your edit was bad, but I think that the ...
user avatar
4 votes
Accepted

May I ask this question?

Your question is not appropriate for this site. We don't allow site reviews We don't allow open ended questions (StackExchange software works best when there can be one "correct" answer) I don' ...
user avatar
3 votes

I don't think this question should be put on hold

This question should remain closed for two reasons: In it's current form it links to the current page for review. That makes it specific for one website which is off-topic here. Removing it would ...
user avatar
  • 85.7k
3 votes

Why was this closed and only by one person?

This was closed by one of the four moderators here. Moderators can close questions on their own. It wasn't closed because it can't be answered. It was closed as off-topic because it's a ...
user avatar
3 votes
Accepted

Can someone review my disappearing comments?

Comments are designed to contain ephemeral, short-lived discussions surrounding the parent post, and it's expected that anything meaningful resulting from the conversations be moved into the post ...
user avatar
  • 6,436
2 votes

Can someone review my disappearing comments?

I can imagine that it is a very tough job moderating a site like this one. Indeed, other Stack Exchanges sites are far more active and the job much larger. Personality, expertise, and experience will ...
user avatar
  • 32.5k
2 votes

Question about "force downloads" incorrectly migrated to SuperUser.com?

Initially the question looked to be solvable by modifying the headers, so I left a comment with some related suggestions. However, after further comments from the OP as to what was tried, some testing ...
user avatar
  • 15k
2 votes

A questions about affiliate software was inappropriately closed as a duplicate of a question about content management systems

Looks like that question is over six years old (from 2011), and since it's seeking a recommendation for software, which is considered off-topic for this site, it can't be reopened. If you check our ...
user avatar
  • 15k
1 vote

A questions about affiliate software was inappropriately closed as a duplicate of a question about content management systems

I have unmarked the question as a duplicate and re-closed is with the more appropriate reason: Questions asking for recommended external websites, tools, resources, and software are off-topic as ...
user avatar
1 vote

What about this DDoS question?

Limit yourself to one question. You have a bullet list of multiple questions. The question is too broad because it is asking too many things. Your sub-question "Is there any commercially-...
user avatar
1 vote

My question is on hold; please review and remove "on hold" from it

When you edited the question, it automatically entered the "reopen queue". This allows users of the site that have sufficient reputation to look at the questions that were closed and vote to reopen ...
user avatar

Only top scored, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible