1

There are many questions with the tag , and many questions are about: my site isn't being indexed by Google! or I can't see my website in the Google search results!

Should there be a catch-all post which will be redirected to as a duplicate when there's such a new question? This would result in:

  • less questions
  • one place with the most common problems and their solutions regarding this topic
1

A large percentage of questions on Pro Webmasters (approximately 1/4 of the total) are related to SEO issues, so prematurely closing them as duplicates would hamper the opportunity to cover new and additional information, and could stunt activity on the site.

Before flagging a question as a duplicate of another one, see if there are significant differences between them. For example, the question Why isn't my website in Google search results from 2010 is specific to search results appearing in Google's index (not the other search engines), and hasn't ever been tagged with SEO either (i.e., it's asking about Google's indexing, not necessarily about optimizing content, etc...).

There can be enumerable variations of questions related to SEO issues, so we should be careful not to reduce such a large and active topic here down into a single question. As conveyed by Jeff Atwood (co-founder of Stack Exchange) here and linked to in our Help Center's documentation under
Asking:

There are similar questions, yes, and so-called “exact” duplicates do happen, but they are kind of rare in my experience. It’s far more common to have many subtle variations of a question. I think that’s OK, because that’s how the world works. Trying to shoehorn a bunch of semi-related things into one arbitrary container in service of some Highlander-ish “there can be only one” rule is ultimately harmful. Remember: while there are aspects of wiki to our system, we are not Wikipedia. There is not one canonical question about every possible subject. Rather, there are many.

If questions are exact or near-exact duplicates, marking them as such helps to reduce redundancy on the site. If there are significant differences that might be important to the OP or future visitors however, doing so will limit information on the site, frustrate users, and likely reduce new activity on the site.

Therefore, questions should ideally be flagged and marked as duplicates judiciously, and not just because they seem similar or might be answered in another question. You can always add a comment to a related question instead, like: See this related question ....

2

Any question that asks why a site isn't indexed should be marked a duplicate of this question from 2010: Why isn't my website in Google search results?

There are lots of questions about SEO that are new and interesting. I don't see a need for a catch-all SEO question.

  • > There are lots of questions about SEO that are new and interesting. I don't see a need for a catch-all SEO question. - I agree, but many are just duplicates of common problems. In that case, we should mark them as a duplicate from the 2010 post you posted here. – William Edwards Sep 19 '14 at 17:06
  • 2
    That's what we do. If you see a new question that had not yet been marked as a dupe of that question be sure to flag it so a moderator can close it properly. – John Conde Sep 19 '14 at 22:23

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .